Challenge a Claim with Balanced Evidence
Evaluate a claim by tracing its evidence to original sources, assessing research quality, and explaining what is known and uncertain.
Prompt template
- Format
- Text Parameterized
- Inputs
- claim (text) · Required
- Outputs
- balanced_evidence_review (text)
Act as a skeptical academic reviewer examining this claim: ${claim}. Find the strongest supporting and opposing evidence, trace claims to original sources, evaluate research quality, examine sample sizes and methodological weaknesses, and identify conflicts of interest. Deliver a balanced verdict explaining what the evidence establishes, what remains uncertain, and what would change the conclusion.
Replace the ${…} placeholders with your values
before using this prompt. See parameters
and defaults below
Parameters
Replace each placeholder with your own value, or use its default when one is provided
${claim}
claim
Required
What you'll create
An academic-style critique traces sources, reviews sample sizes and methods and checks conflicts of interest. The conclusion explains what is supported, uncertain and capable of changing the verdict.
Frequently asked questions
Does skepticism mean rejecting the claim automatically?
No. The strongest supporting and opposing evidence both receive attention.
What should the verdict clarify?
What the evidence establishes and what remains uncertain.
Comments
Tried this prompt? Share what you made, compare results, or ask a question