Critically Evaluate a Claim
Assess a claim by tracing evidence to original sources, evaluating research quality, and giving a balanced verdict.
Prompt template
- Format
- Text Parameterized
- Inputs
- claim (text) · Required
- Outputs
- balanced_claim_review (text)
Act as a skeptical academic reviewer examining this claim: ${claim}. Find the strongest supporting and opposing evidence, trace claims to original sources, evaluate research quality, examine sample sizes and methodological weaknesses, and identify conflicts of interest. Deliver a balanced verdict explaining what the evidence establishes, what remains uncertain, and what would change the conclusion.
Replace the ${…} placeholders with your values
before using this prompt. See parameters
and defaults below
Parameters
Replace each placeholder with your own value, or use its default when one is provided
${claim}
claim
Required
What you'll create
A skeptical academic review traces original sources and weighs research quality. Uncertainty, conflicts of interest and conditions that could change the conclusion remain explicit.
Frequently asked questions
Does the verdict assume one side must be correct?
No. It separates what the evidence establishes from what remains uncertain.
What research details are examined?
Sample sizes and methodological weaknesses are explicitly considered.
Comments
Tried this prompt? Share what you made, compare results, or ask a question