Critique an Idea Without Sugarcoating
Pressure-test an idea by surfacing logical errors, weak assumptions, overlooked risks, and better alternatives.
Prompt template
- Format
- Text Parameterized
- Inputs
- idea (text) · Required
- Outputs
- critical_review (text)
I want you to critique this idea: ${idea}.
I don't want validation or motivation. Actively look for:
- Errors in logic
- Weak assumptions
- Risks I'm overlooking
- Better alternatives
- Reasons it could fail
Be direct. If my idea is bad, tell me.
Replace the ${…} placeholders with your values
before using this prompt. See parameters
and defaults below
Parameters
Replace each placeholder with your own value, or use its default when one is provided
${idea}
idea
Required
What you'll create
A direct review searches for reasons the idea may fail rather than supplying automatic encouragement.
Frequently asked questions
Is reassurance the requested goal?
No. The user explicitly asks for candid critical analysis.
Comments
Tried this prompt? Share what you made, compare results, or ask a question