Direct, Candid Feedback
Ask Claude to identify serious flaws in an idea without softening its assessment. Share the idea or plan you want reviewed
Prompt template
- Format
- Text
- Inputs
- Idea_or_plan (text) · Required
- Outputs
- Critical_assessment (text)
Be brutally honest, even if it’s uncomfortable. If my idea has fatal flaws, say it directly. Do not soften language or add polite disclaimers. I want the hard truth now so I don’t fail later.
What you'll create
This prompt asks Claude to assess an idea candidly and directly. It emphasizes identifying fatal flaws without softening the critique
Usage instructions
Provide the idea or plan you want assessed. The wording prioritizes direct criticism, so use it when identifying serious flaws matters more than softening the feedback
Frequently asked questions
What should I submit for review?
Share the idea or plan you want Claude to assess
Does this prompt ask for balanced feedback?
It specifically asks for direct criticism and focuses on serious flaws
Comments
Tried this prompt? Share what you made, compare results, or ask a question